kasg wrote on Apr 10
th, 2013 at 1:21pm:
I'm not sure how helpful it is to report every apparent failure of the 111 service here, and there will doubtless be many reported in the papers - it isn't really a telecoms issue. In this case, I think most people are rather puzzled as to why he didn't use the 999 service earlier.
Hear Hear!
Had the initial call in question been made to NHS Direct on 0845 4647, rather than 111, then the caller would have had to call again to make contact with the GP out of hours service for the area. This could have been through a 084 number used by their GP or directly to the out of hours provider, some of whom use 084 numbers. It may be that subsequent calls to chase up would have been answered more promptly, although hanging on for an answer on 111, at no cost to the caller, may have been cheaper than hanging on for an answer on another number. (It was not the actual call cost which caused the caller to hang up and try again later during the day.)
This is a most unhappy story, but the issues raised are not directly related to the choice of telephone number for 111. There may be an indirect relationship …
One fears that the most significant point may be the failure to rigidly enforce the principle that 111 is only for
urgent, but non-emergency cases. The health information and advice telephone service offered by NHS Direct to cover non-urgent cases is being withdrawn. This information and advice is largely still available from other sources, but it is uneconomic to provide it in parallel with a telephone service intended for urgent cases, where calls need to be answered promptly. If, as may have happened in this case, the subsequent calls to 111 were not answered promptly because agents were dealing with non-urgent cases, then an argument could be made for setting a charge for calling 111. I would not support such an argument, but if the resources cannot be committed to 111 to ensure prompt access for urgent callers, then steps must be taken to stop 111 being used unnecessarily. One hopes that charging would be the last option to be considered!